No forum for Seven Years War?

Forum for the Musket & Pike games series
User avatar
Verdun1916
Posts: 279
Joined: Sun Jul 10, 2022 8:42 am
Location: Hässleholm, Sweden

Re: No forum for Seven Years War?

Post by Verdun1916 »

S Trauth wrote: Thu Jul 14, 2022 9:47 pm --Actually I remember reading there were mounted dragoons with pikes in the Thirty Years War- what actual use they had- who knows ... it wasn't like you could mount and dismount units with pike and then have them form a block.
Depending on the pike length they could have possibly been used as lancers. then again Dragoons during the Thirty Years War was just mounted infantry. And not all infantry fought in blocks. The Swedish Army, fought in lines for example. A loot deeper lines though than we see later on though. And the Swedish tactics spread to all units under Swedish command during the latter half of the war.
So yes, mounted pikemen in a dragoon unit could certainly have dismounted and fought as regular pikemen on foot to "späcka linjen" (fill the line) according to the Swedish model. Atleast in theory.
However I have never heard that the Swedish dragoons, or dragoons under Swedish command, included pikemen though.
S Trauth
Posts: 26
Joined: Sat Jul 09, 2022 6:54 am
Contact:

Re: No forum for Seven Years War?

Post by S Trauth »

No - you wouldn't code them as lancers; the primary function would be on foot, just like your dragoon example; to be fair though, I think I'd seen mention of it first (and maybe only) -European Weapons and Warfare 1618 - 1648 -which I think was from at least the 1970's when it was first published.

I never saw any mention of them in orders of battle or mention of use of them in battle, so I expect if it did happen at all, it would have been in the earlier portion of the war, and probably from some of the German states -if it happened at all. I expect it didn't work all that well, and they disappeared entirely. And I don't claim to be an expert on mounted pike dragoon types - just meant I saw it in passing on the above book's section on mounted troops.

The Swedish style, even was adopted by Wallenstein, with the lighter, more mobile artillery as well -so yes, there was a lot of tactical evolution during that period; technically the 17th Century as a whole as I think the bayonet got introduced near the end of the 17th century - which began making the need for massed pike formations redundant.
User avatar
Verdun1916
Posts: 279
Joined: Sun Jul 10, 2022 8:42 am
Location: Hässleholm, Sweden

Re: No forum for Seven Years War?

Post by Verdun1916 »

S Trauth wrote: Mon Aug 22, 2022 5:42 pm No - you wouldn't code them as lancers; the primary function would be on foot, just like your dragoon example; to be fair though, I think I'd seen mention of it first (and maybe only) -European Weapons and Warfare 1618 - 1648 -which I think was from at least the 1970's when it was first published.

I never saw any mention of them in orders of battle or mention of use of them in battle, so I expect if it did happen at all, it would have been in the earlier portion of the war, and probably from some of the German states -if it happened at all. I expect it didn't work all that well, and they disappeared entirely. And I don't claim to be an expert on mounted pike dragoon types - just meant I saw it in passing on the above book's section on mounted troops.

The Swedish style, even was adopted by Wallenstein, with the lighter, more mobile artillery as well -so yes, there was a lot of tactical evolution during that period; technically the 17th Century as a whole as I think the bayonet got introduced near the end of the 17th century - which began making the need for massed pike formations redundant.
Didn't mean they were used as lancers, but rather that they could hve been in a pinch if the pikes had been short enough. Sorry if I was unclear.

But I agree with you, if dragoons ever carried pikes I'm also pretty sure it must have been in the early days of the war and more or less just on a trial basis or out of some sort or extreme necessity were regular pikemen hat to mount up to get somewere quickly.
Considering the lenght of the average infantry pike of the day it would have been extremely unpractical, if not impossible, to carry such a weapon on horseback. So I assume any army or unit that tried giving such pikes to dragoons or mounting regular infantry pikemen must have found out very quickly that it was not worth the effort.
With a shorter weapon, the size of a lance or longer spear, sure, it could have been done off course.

Yes, the Swedish regimental guns are pretty famous. What buggers me though is how much the so called leather cannons gets attention! especially in wargaming circles. They were only manufacturd in a very small number and only used on a trial basis. And this was done during the war in Poland before Sweden entered the 30 Years War in 1630. These leather cannons were quickly proven to be a failure not worth while persuing any further. However those that had been manufacturd and had reached the army was kept in service until they were worn out or lost. It's possible that one or two might have survived to go with the Swedish army to Germany in 1630-31 but I highly doubt it.
Technologically speaking they were an interesting but failed attempt to create an early form of light and mobile artillery. But as a piece of military hardware on the battlefield they were nothing but a side note barely worth mentioning. But still they keep getting attention in popular media and wargaming circles.
User avatar
zovs
Posts: 488
Joined: Sat Jul 09, 2022 11:38 am
Location: Ohio

Re: No forum for Seven Years War?

Post by zovs »

I am looking forward to the third title in the series, the Swedish War. Some of my fondest memories of the Musket and Pike era are from days gone by from SPI and there game by the same name. My times have changed.

https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/115 ... -1550-1680

Image
Image
Beta Tester for: War in the East 1 & 2, WarPlan & WarPlan Pacific, Valor & Victory, Flashpoint Campaigns: Sudden Storm, Computer War In Europe 2
SPWW2 & SPMBT scenario creator
Post Reply